Review +Giveaway: Lure of Shapinsay by Krista Holle

Title: The Lure of Shapinsay
Author: Krista Holle
Series: Standalone
Genre: YA Fantasy
Format: E-book
Source:  Author
Pub. Year: 2012
Purchase: Amz / B&N
I received a free copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

Blurb from Amazon:
Ever since Kait Swanney could remember, the old crones of the village have been warning her to stay away from the selkies. They claim that like sirens of old, the seal men creep from the inky waters, shed their skins, and entice women to their deaths beneath the North Sea. But avoiding an encounter becomes impossible when Kait is spotted at the water’s edge, moments after the murder of a half-selkie infant.

Kait is awoken unexpectedly by a beautiful, naked selkie man seeking revenge. After she declares her innocence, the intruder darts into the night, but not before inadvertently bewitching her with an overpowering lure.

Kait obsesses over a reunion deep beneath the bay and risks her own life to be reunited with her selkie. But when she lands the dangerous lover, the chaos that follows leaves Kait little time to wonder—is it love setting her on fire or has she simply been lured?

Random: Brush on up on 19th century Scottish lingo because as readers, we need it.

Having never read anything about selkies, I was intrigued by the mythology and world-building of the book. It was interesting to learn more about selkies and the inclusion of crazy characters really helped the books. Selkie are seal-men.

One of the things that as readers we have to get use to is the vernacular of the novel. It is written in Scottish English so it is English but it a little hard to understand. Right at the start, the word “bairn” is used and I had no idea what it meant so I’m confused (and maybe you will too) about what is going on within the first three pages. It turns out “bairn” is a child or son but I kept thinking it was an animal. It is also problematic when Eamon, the selkie, refers to the child as a “burd.” It’s bad enough I have decipher Kait’s language to understand what she is saying but I have to guess around with the selkie’s language as well.  There are multiples word that are not commonly heard in American English so that’s a head up about the language. “Haud your wheest” is another phrase that I have not been able to figure out. I think it translates to “Wait a moment.”

Kait, I’m not sure if I like or I don’t like her. She is madly obsess with Eamon the selkie to the point where she nearly kills herself just trying to find him in the ocean. She is consumed with madness which makes her an interesting character because she is crazy. But she is boy-crazy and I don’t like women who define themselves by their male partners and that is what Kait is doing. It’s hard to believe she honestly cares for Eamon (at the start of the novel) because she is a madly obsessive with him. It felt like that she didn’t love Eamon for who he was but what he was. Kait is fascinated by the idea of a selkie, that’s what she loves. She is adamant in forming a relationship with him that doesn’t feel real. Even at the end of the novel, there is still a little lingering thought that she likes him because of what he is but most of their love feels real by the end.

Eamon’s thoughts on Kait and his not-obsession but interest in Kait feels more genuine than Kait’s interest in Eamon. He doesn’t go through the near-death experiences. He is more curious and tries to learn more about her. He adapts to her ways which is hard for him to do. I was surprised to learn how young he was. That is a shocker. A great deal of the novel deals with Eamon trying to live on land and do right by Kait. He has to change what he is in order to live with her which drastically change him as a person. The good thing is that Kait does see the change and worries about it (more about what it means for her instead of him) but she does see that her way is hurting him so she does right by him in the end.

The romance of the novel (for me) feels forced and riddled with a love obsession that appear to become genuine is the end so that is the good thing. We do learn the selkie are bound to the sea for good reason. Tipper is the prime example of what can happen to selkie who are land bound. She is crazy, a nice word for her. She keeps looking for her seal skin so she can return to the sea but she is having trouble finding it. She now hates being on land and is growing old (which selkies are not meant to grow old). If Eamon stays on the land, she is what he will become. Tipper is the warning of what is to come but it is through Tipper that Kait realizes her dream of being with Eamon.  She is a double-edged sword.

Overall, it was interesting story that details the path of an obsession to true love. At least two of the characters are borderline mad which always makes for a great book.

4 BB-Ready for capture


37th in the 150+ Reading Challenge
Also qualifies for: E-book, Self-published, Where are you reading?-Scotland



Krista has kindly offer to a giveaway package to an international reader. This package includes a paperback copy of the novel, a T-shirt, bookmarks and bookplates. Sounds pretty good to me.

All you have to do to enter is leave a comment answering the question “Do you like the ocean?” and leave your e-mail.

Giveaway ends with on May 25.


Good luck!

Posted on May 11, 2012, in Book Reviews and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 22 Comments.

  1. andreea martes

    Yes I like the ocean very much, seen from the picture and movies and described in books. I didn’t saw the ocean live but I would love to feel the breeze on my face and smell the ocean.
    Thanks for the giveaway.
    My email is :

  2. Love the ocean, love seeing the waves and feeling the breeze that blows off of it. It is amazing to look at and think about.
    Great giveaway.
    skpetal at hotmail dot com

  3. I am really quite afraid of the ocean. It is so intimidating. I had an accident at an ocean beach when I was younger and almost drowned.

    • Oh, I’m so sorry to hear that. The ocean can be overpowering at times and almost drowning doesn’t help to feel feelings the ocean can evoke.

      • I was 6 and this huge wave came and the next thing I knew, people were on top of me while I was still underwater. I opened my eyes, got scared, and inhaled. Next thing I know I’m lying on the beach with all kinds of people around me. Wasn’t a good time.

  4. Filia Oktarina

    I don’t very much like ocean, because i can stand hot. I like see picture or tv program about creature in ocean. But if for vacation or swim, i prefer doing in lake at village:)
    Thank you for giveaway and making international.

    filiafantasy at gmail dot com

  5. I love the ocean. It’s so big and fierce! I also love just sitting and watching the waves, it always helps me think. I’ve always wanted to live by the coast, but haven’t had the opportunity yet. I can only image how great it would be to be a selki or a mermaid or something and be able to swim off into the deep water and just forget about the rest of the world 🙂

  6. I love the ocean. It’s never the same. The waves are always different in size and shape. There are so many different sea creatures. It’s just gorgeous, so calming to look at, yet so dangerous. When I look at it, my imagination goes wild!

  7. I do like it. It’s fun to look at its vast peacefulness.
    Great review by the way.

    Thanks Krista for this awesome giveaway as well.

    E-mail: bookandmoviedimensionblogger [at] yahoo [dot]

  8. Yes, i LOVE the ocean (as long as im on a boat). LOL i don’t know how to swim. haha but the sea breeze, the shades of blue, the sound of the waves. it’s the perfect place to be. i always dream of living near a beach and just read and read and read.

  9. I love the ocean! I think the sound of the surf is so soothing! Thanks for this giveaway – I would love to win!

    susanw28 (at) mindspring (dot) com

  10. Ooh I love the ocean, I like all water bodies since there’s none near where I live.

  11. I like the ocean but I have to have with me a bag of lollipops. I don’t like the taste of salt water near my mouth. 🙂

  12. Courtney Wyant

    Do I like the ocean? Heck, we go 15 times a year and we live away 15 hours…

  13. I love the ocean, and am lucky enough to live near it.

  14. I love the ocean, mostly I love the sound of the waves rolling in! Thank you for the great giveaway, The Lure of Shapinsay has been on my to-read list!

    booksaresanity at yahoo dot com

  15. Terri Russell

    I love the ocean. I don’t leave close, but we have vacationed several times and I would love to live by the ocean. Thanks for the great contest. Would love to win this book to add to my library!

  16. Jennifer Metz

    I love the ocean, I just live too far away to see it very often =(
    Thanks for the awesome giveaway!
    draoi7383 @

  17. I love the ocean but prefer to long on the beach than swim in the ocean. Although I wouldn’t hesitate to jump in if lured by a Selkie!

  18. I love looking at the ocean and laying on the beach, Getting in the ocean is a completely different story. I am always paranoid that a shark is going to come eat me or something and have never been able to truly enjoy myself.

  19. I have never seen the ocean in real life but I have seen it on movies and read about it and it sounds like something I would love to see for real one day.

    fullmoonbites @ gmail . com

Leave a message, it can be lonely in Hades

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: